|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
Life is 42 4th Year


 Registration date: 2006-03-06 Number of posts: 2778 Age: 20 Location: what ARE you, a stalker???? go away! Real First Name: Ann-but please call me Lifey. Country:  House: RAVENCLAW! Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2270
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Sara Marsh Race: Witch Good or Evil: Order of the Phoenix
 | Subject: Hermione's Love Potion Fri 14 Apr - 7:05 | |
| Okay! We know that when Hermione smells the love potion in Slughorns room she smells parchment, freshly mown grass and...she cuts off. I was listening to the GoF audio book and came to the part where the Weasleys, Harry, and Hermione are having dinner in the garden before the World Cup. there is a section where the book mentions the smell of grass and hunnysuckle. Now! if we go by the assumption that one of harry's smells is something flowery from the burrow that we later learn was Ginny's perfume/sent w/e...couldn't we conclude that if Hermioine really does like Ron, the other thing she smells in the potion is hunnysuck? I hope i posted this in the right place. I thought it fit more under HBP than ship discussion...but don't kill me if i made a mistake please! Tell me what you think of this!
Life |
|
 | |
cookiemonster 5th Year


 Registration date: 2006-02-22 Number of posts: 3086 Age: 18 Location: your mom's house. House: Huffieeee Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2281
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Brittany Alexander Race: Witch Good or Evil: Neutral
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sun 23 Apr - 19:18 | |
| i think you posted this in the right place, life, dont worry
i always thought the smell had something to do with ron, but if she smelled honeysuckle, why do you think she cut off before she said it? Honeysuckle isn't really an embaressing thing to like the smell of. but i think it has something to do with Ron or the Burrow.... its quite obvious, actually.
hearts :cherry: |
|
 | |
Life is 42 4th Year


 Registration date: 2006-03-06 Number of posts: 2778 Age: 20 Location: what ARE you, a stalker???? go away! Real First Name: Ann-but please call me Lifey. Country:  House: RAVENCLAW! Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2270
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Sara Marsh Race: Witch Good or Evil: Order of the Phoenix
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Mon 24 Apr - 0:39 | |
| my theory is that the hunysuckle reminded her of Ron...or connects to Ron in some way. Since the only thing that Harry thought of when he smelled Ginny's sent was 'burrow'...my thoughts anyways Life |
|
 | |
polly 7th Year


 Registration date: 2006-03-12 Number of posts: 10715 Age: 19 Location: England Real First Name: Polly Country:  House: Ravenclaw! Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2465
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Polly Swindail Race: Witch Good or Evil: Dumbledores Army
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sun 30 Apr - 14:56 | |
| how is huonysuckle related to Ron i just think she smelt Ron and thats it nothing more to it mabey she just likes the smell of the other thing. |
|
 | |
Life is 42 4th Year


 Registration date: 2006-03-06 Number of posts: 2778 Age: 20 Location: what ARE you, a stalker???? go away! Real First Name: Ann-but please call me Lifey. Country:  House: RAVENCLAW! Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2270
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Sara Marsh Race: Witch Good or Evil: Order of the Phoenix
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sun 30 Apr - 18:57 | |
| it's like a missing moments thing...like, maybe she and Ron were having a moonlit chat or something ya know? hhmmmmm *contemplates fic idea* |
|
 | |
Amy Retired Deputy Head : 7th year


 Registration date: 2006-02-22 Number of posts: 11742 Age: 24 Location: England Real First Name: Amy Country:  House: Gryffindor Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 3064
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Fri 12 May - 16:49 | |
| I think that she smelled Ron in that potion - there would have been no need for her to cut off talking otherwise.
Now - another question regarding Ron and Hermione's relationship:
Are they already together? The books are from Harry's PoV, and so we don't always get to see everything that goes on in the other characters lives. Ron and Hermione seemed pretty close at DD's funeral, so does anyone think that they are already together?
Or are they just getting there and their relationship will begin in book 7? |
|
 | |
Traci=Ronlover102 5th Year


 Registration date: 2006-02-25 Number of posts: 3089 Age: 19 Location: Drowning in a mass of homework. BRB Real First Name: Traci Country:  House: Gryffindor Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2477
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Traci Brittle/and Elizabeth brittle Race: Witch Good or Evil: Neutral
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sat 27 May - 4:43 | |
| you people may not be in the wrong place but i think i am Hermione sent of honysuckle reminds me of her and harry's hogesmead weekend you know the one he snuck out to go. I think it connect to harry and harry is perfect for hermione and vise versa NOT GINNY. sorry to people who dissagree |
|
 | |
Slash 1st Year


 Registration date: 2006-06-07 Number of posts: 12 Age: 19 Location: At My House House: Ravenclaw Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2176
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Tue 13 Jun - 2:37 | |
| Hermione most likely smelled something from the Burrow that Ron would recognize on the spot. I imagine that a 'Ron' scent would be more of a 'guy' smell, more stinky than sweet. |
|
 | |
Just_Ginny 7th Year


 Registration date: 2006-02-26 Number of posts: 10804 Age: 20 Location: I Own Harry's Quidditch Pants-So where am I? Real First Name: Rachel House: Hufflepuff! HUFF PUFF BADGERS FOR THE WIN! Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2267
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Rachel Everett Race: Witch Good or Evil: Dumbledores Army
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Mon 31 Jul - 15:27 | |
| Maybe Honeysuckle reminded her of the Weasley's garden? And then she was about to say something like, I don't know, something she smelt during her Hogsmeade visit with Ron (the one where it looked like she'd had the most fun in her whole life) |
|
 | |
Ilyria 4th Year


 Registration date: 2006-09-20 Number of posts: 2448 Age: 26 Location: IN MY GINGERBREAD HOUSE NEXT TO AMBY IN THE GAMES FORUM IM ADOPTED BY GINNY AND FATED!! Real First Name: Lizzie House: Ravenclaw: THE OFFICIAL H.E. GHOST! Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2066
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Wed 27 Sep - 13:49 | |
| Im not even sure that there is anything in this theory (no offense lol). Personally, smells can be similar and can remind you of all different things - i mean, that smell couldnt only be associated with the burrow and ron could it? |
|
 | |
Snapes_girl 6th Year


 Registration date: 2006-10-24 Number of posts: 6269 Age: 27 Location: Indiana Real First Name: Nancy Country:  House: Slytherin - Where I have always belonged Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2045
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Sky Summers Race: Witch Good or Evil: Deatheater
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sun 26 Nov - 18:03 | |
| Maybe it was a smell she smells when she is in the borrow and doesn't want Ron to put two and two together, or maybe it's a smell she knows when she is around Harry? |
|
 | |
KatieBellaTrix 6th Year


 Registration date: 2006-10-24 Number of posts: 5236 Age: 18 Location: Jersey Girl Through && Through Real First Name: Let's Leave it at Katie... XD Country:  House: Gryffindor Girlie Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2060
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Race: Good or Evil:
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Tue 28 Nov - 21:14 | |
| Oooh!! I didn't notice that! I did notice Harry, and Ginny's perfume but thats a really good point. I am a believer in the Hermione=Ron romance so this makes sense! |
|
 | |
stephy Head Girl : Graduate : Death Eater


 Registration date: 2006-06-04 Number of posts: 29932 Age: 21 Location: At the Cullen's house stealing Jasper Real First Name: Stephanie, Polly calls me Stephums, Kim calls me Steffie and among others Im either mommy or granny Country:  House: ravenclaw Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 8701
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Oddie Riddle; Mathew Riddle; Scelestus; Mark Race: Werewolf Good or Evil: Spy for the Order
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sun 1 Apr - 3:08 | |
| i think that hermine and ron will get together after reading the books and watching the movies. you can see that her and ron are getting closer and closer as the sereis progress and i wouldnt be surprised if this happened _________________ I am Nelstyny Seraph Nieme! Fear me! Melviphy group Lady Luna Elms Reslad and Jester Nema Neatie Law Need to get ahold of me right away?? Facebook message me or send me an owl. I'll get back once I'm done watching pokemon or playing LoTRO :D |
|
 | |
Gryffindorgal4hp 7th Year


 Registration date: 2008-02-14 Number of posts: 7973 Age: 18 Location: On stage, singing with Adam Lambert! Real First Name: Lucy Country:  House: Gryffindor Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 2042
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Natalie Alexandra Patterson Race: Vampire Good or Evil: Spy for the Order
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Sun 25 May - 12:48 | |
| Here's my theory.
If you have noticed, everyone's hair has a different smell, so I would guess Hermione smelt Ron's hair scent in the potion.
That's what I think.
LucyXX |
|
 | |
stephy Head Girl : Graduate : Death Eater


 Registration date: 2006-06-04 Number of posts: 29932 Age: 21 Location: At the Cullen's house stealing Jasper Real First Name: Stephanie, Polly calls me Stephums, Kim calls me Steffie and among others Im either mommy or granny Country:  House: ravenclaw Crest:  Warning: Award Bar: Contribution Points: 8701
RPG Forum : Great Hall RPG Character Name: Oddie Riddle; Mathew Riddle; Scelestus; Mark Race: Werewolf Good or Evil: Spy for the Order
 | Subject: Re: Hermione's Love Potion Thu 19 Aug - 5:56 | |
| Lucy you're right. I ran across an interview with JK and she said that it was his hair. She said that everyone has distinct smelling hair or something like that. _________________ I am Nelstyny Seraph Nieme! Fear me! Melviphy group Lady Luna Elms Reslad and Jester Nema Neatie Law Need to get ahold of me right away?? Facebook message me or send me an owl. I'll get back once I'm done watching pokemon or playing LoTRO :D |
|
 | |
|